January 10th, 2009 by yaman | Posted in Comment | 6 Comments »
Background: On Nov 13, 2008, three members of the Zionist Freedom Alliance, including current ASUC Senator John Moghtader, stormed up several flights of stairs in Eshleman Hall to confront three Palestinian students who silently held Palestinian flags on a balcony above a ZFA event to protest the group’s anti-Palestinian message. An altercation ensued in which the Palestinian students claim they were attacked by the ZFA members, and the ZFA members claim the opposite. UCPD recommended charges be filed against the ZFA members, but the DA did not press charges. Now the Zionist Organization of America intervenes, likely at the request of members of the ZFA or Tikvah.
A few days ago, Morton Klein of the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA) issued a press release urging UC Berkeley Chancellor Birgeneau to address “Campus Anti-Semitism and Israel-Bashing.” The phone contact was in the 212 area code, nowhere close to Berkeley. Remember that, because it tells us much of what we need to know to see how flawed the ZOA’s press release and letter to Birgeneau (which reads like the pre-cursor to a lawsuit) are.
There are many contentious and mostly false claims made in the ZOA’s press release, but I will focus primarily on the sections related to the Nov 13 attack on Palestinian students as well as the ensuing recall election of John Moghtader, the Senator who was kicked out of the SQUELCH party, president of Tikvah, and sponsor of the ASUC bill funding the Zionist Freedom Alliance (ZFA) concert.
I will disclose, if it is not obvious already, that I believe in the victims’ narrative of what happened, that after they silently hung a Palestinian flag in protest on a balcony above a concert for the ZFA–an organization which openly advocates the “elimination” of Palestinians–three ZFA organizers, including Moghtader, ran up several flights of stairs to confront the Palestinian students on the balcony. I will concede, however, that besides people close to either “side” of this encounter, who tend to believe their friends, no third party in Berkeley has really bothered or felt confident enough to take a stand either way. That includes the Daily Californian, the Berkeley Daily Planet, Jewish News Weekly SF, the Dean of Students, Chancellor Birgeneau, and the District Attorney, all of whom agree on only one thing: that they can’t decide who to believe because the evidence consists of diametrically opposed stories coming from the attackers and the victims. Someone is lying, but nobody can decide who. Read the rest of this entry »